Jump to content
Talbot Michaels

Welcome Guest!

Welcome to UK Pagan; The Valley

Like most online communities we require you to register for an account before we give you access to read and post.

Only a small number of our forum areas can be read without registering for an account.

Please consider supporting us to help keep our Website and Facebook groups online. Become a Patron!

Reincarnation And Karma

Guest Shimmering Stardust

Recommended Posts

Also like to put, Its funny though how we get enraged by others who think our way is crap. So far i have never really got that angry because of people thinking my faith is crap. In fact i find humour in it most of the time. No skin off my nose. Though plenty of jokes about horny beasts joke and whatnots.

But for someone who has a real go at someone who disergrees,. but then says those who believe in crop circles are knobheads.

Well surely then you are no worse than me for saying karma is crap.

I also find in these situations is just to say. IMO and leave it at that. Then change the subject to tea or the weather is the best route of action.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Please consider supporting us to help keep our Website and Facebook groups online.

  • Replies 96
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Pomona


  • Moonhunter


  • Xalle


Arty, both your last two posts on this thread sort of make sense. Are you feeling ok?! :P :o :P :o_baeh: :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Arty, both your last two posts on this thread sort of make sense.  Are you feeling ok?!  :P  :o  :P  :o_baeh:  :)



no. i feel all light headed and woozy :D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 4 months later...

Hmmm, this is an interesting one :). I hold a belief in reincarnation, a mixture of disliking the idea that there is only one "shot" that is inconsequential to anything other than ourselves and a great yearning for the concept that life is about spiritual, emotional, maturity and skill improvement/development that we may all become better people. (There will be many :rolleyes: at this point :D ) But also some of the things I have heard or seen lead me to believe that this is a plausible belief, general examples include things like seriously gifted children who on first encountering a piano play like well established masters, people holding accurate and precise knowledge of things or locations of which in this life they held no prior experience of. Some of this may be due to the fact that I have no personal belief in coincidence, coincidence in the chaos of creation is far too pattern like to my mind, a human concept designed to help make sense of things.


I have also had personal moments, usually involving other people, where upon meeting for the first time, you know them, I don't mean in a vague "god your familiar" way, but you know hard facts about them, seemingly without ever having met them before. I must stress at this point that this is a very rare occurrence, it has happened only twice in 28 years. So yes I believe in reincarnation, hope that the belief is not unfounded and most of all look forward to discovering if it is so :D.


My understanding of Karma is not one of direct consequences, as is often presented in the "cosmic score sheet" way. The idea that anyones challenges in this life are the direct consequence of actions in a previous life, is frankly to me, a little ridiculous. What makes more sense to my mind and the belief set within which I operate, is that in every life time we each have lessons that are to be learned (cue debate on predestination or not... ;) ) if in a previous life a lesson was not completed, that lesson will repeat in the next. Or as is often the case in the same life lessons will repeat, over and over and over, if so required, until learned.


But it becomes much more complicated than mere personal progression, I believe that everything shares a connection, through this connection we are influenced by others Karma, by involvement in the lessons they (or it) are learning. This may, or may not, be directly a part of our own lessons, as often in life we are presented with challenges and people that reflect ourselves, or things that we wish to improve upon. I can only wrap my head partially around the concept, with the use of the ripple effect, we each create ripples, these ripples affect everything around us, just as we are affected by the other ripples. But this is inadequate in completely explaining the concept, as it is not one that can easily be put into words.


As for the negative/positive aspect of Karma, it makes sense to me (due to connectedness) that if you surround yourself with negativity, you will receive negativity (or attract it) the same can be said of positivity. However this is not a will less process, we each hold the power to create our own realities and indeed to shape and direct them (otherwise the lessons are pointless right?). So we must each actively take part in and take responsibility for, our actions and progression, nothing will be given to us without effort on our parts, either "good" or "bad" ( these concepts themselves are clunky and inadequate, what is bad for one will be good for another). Karma is more a guide and teacher as we walk our paths, rather than a vengeful entity hell bent on retribution.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Karma - Bollocks more like - a load of hogwash made up by rich buggers to keep the proletariat in line and not have their minds in bettering their lot through the likes of revolution.


It goes something like this:


I am a peasant – I work hard – I want more – I deserve more – please sir – I want some more.


To which the caste system/ class system /Karma says – Sorry mate you is a peon, a serf, the scratching of your master’s chocolate salty balls – ergo you cannot have more – be happy – work hard and if you’re good you get to get a better life next time around. If you don’t like it – well that’s tough cos if you start an insurrection your boss will execute every mother**king last one of you, then ship in another load of peons from mountains to replace you – have a nice day.


Karma saves all that awkwardness in the aristocracy having to explain the golden rule. It’s a masterful bit of propaganda and even beats Christianity in its passive aggressive approach. Absolutely brilliant.


As for karma in its western translation – i.e. cause and effect – now that I can understand.




Stimulus: Upset local Deity – Invest in Copper roofing to avoid inevitable lightning strike


Effect: Flash Flood, then Earthquake, then forest fire.





Link to comment
Share on other sites

I hold a belief in reincarnation, a mixture of disliking the idea that there is only one "shot" that is inconsequential to anything other than ourselves and a great yearning for the concept that life is about spiritual, emotional, maturity and skill improvement/development that we may all become better people.


I think this is why a lot of folk have a belief in reincarnation........... but I can't see how "disliking" the idea of death and "yearning" for perpetual betterment can lead to a genuine belief. When deciding whether to believe in something or not shouldn't we try to ignore what we want the answer to be and focus on actual reasons to believe. I could want the Moon to be made of the finest cheddar, doesn't mean to say that believing it is so isn't self dellusional. Things in this World are very often not as we would like them to be.



Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think I lack the eloquoence to put my thoughts across properly, so I'll use the simple langauage I'm stuck with:P I'm not sure at all about karma as we are presented with it. My personal view is things are all inter connected-much like the Indra's web. I have a half baked gut feeling it's all connected a la Charles F Haanel-esque plane of thought. But then I'm probably way off the mark there, as someone earlier said more of a suspicion... We are all this seething mass of thought and intent and our actions and thoughts ripple out, how far that ripple goes can be very short or very far. One man's thoughts might spark a revolution and change the course of history, my postman however will be shaping the course of his tea time:P

Reincarnation..again I dunno...there have been past life regressions where the person in question has absoloutely no way on this earth they can know what they do. There may be an explanantion for those instances-but I have yet to see them. Maybe all of this is a coping mechanism for the bleak reality of it? Who knows? I think if there is nothing at all, then it kinda makes the concept of morality pointless, if there is no comeback then you might as well just do what you want as long you have the strength and the will to carry it through.

That thought makes me shiver, as there are far to many in this world doing that already from warlords to numpty dictators.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Ellinas
      As I have said before, I knew on another forum, and maintain an occasional contact with even now, a person who was known to see himself as a Christian witch.  Pagan?  Well he was on a pagan forum and fitted in very well, and his concept of deity was not such as would be safely mentioned in many a Christian gathering.   Us lot, learned?  More like Moonsmith's favoured image of the "old farts" on a park bench.  If the concepts have no use to you, I'd leave them be - otherwise you are in danger of joining the realm of "Old Fartdom"
    • Moonsmith
      Up to you Nettle but I wouldn’t bother if I were in your place.  I think that your approach to your beliefs is where it needs to be right now.  This thread will move on and fade away.  I’ve done research because I give talks on belief and need to know from which end of my food tube I’m talking.  There are always Pagans in the audience who know their stuff.     What we believe is what we really believe - that might be as good a definition of Paganism as any.  There is no “truth” except our own.  Share what you will but never let it be a chore. I’m here in the Valley coz it’s fun😄
    • Nettle
      I am not as learned as most here when it comes to paganism and even religion.    Hence why I do not usually get involved in such discussions. It’s not that I don’t see value in someone analysing their belief system and tagging the most appropriate label. It’s just for me it’s not that important.    I don’t know what I am, and to be honest I am not really concerned. Yeah it assists in communication but it is not that important to me.    At one time I know I understood the meanings of polytheism/monotheism/atheism etc but I have forgotten what they mean. They have not stuck. And as such they are not required for me to engage with my path.   Lol I am getting older now and so find I have to purge information to allow for more information to be stored! Basically I empty my cup, keep what is useful to me and discard (“forget”) the rest.   However I will endeavour to reacquaint myself with such concepts as they seem to be important to other members here and so may be worth more investigating and gaining different perspective. 
    • Moonsmith
      I agree SH!  Some Irish, Polish and Hispanic versions of Catholicism (Inc. some of their priests) are very like Polytheistic Paganism.  Once Catholicism meets Voodun you’d be hard put to create a definition that divided the practice Catholicism from Paganism.  That said, the Christians in question would object to being called Pagan as I suspect a Voodunista might object to being called Christian but I don’t know that.  I’d keep definitions of religion well away from definitions of Paganism.  I certainly don’t have a religion and I’m Pagan.  The original use of the word Pagani - (those who lived out on the pagus; outside of citified civilisation = rustic) - distinguished between formal Roman polytheists who would be offended at being referred to as Pagani and the rustics who wouldn’t. I wonder if you can be Pagan and not know it?  Is it behaviour related rather than belief based?
    • Stonehugger
      Is it that kind of word though? Where would one find an authority about what it was formally meant to comprise? A dictionary will say how the word is used in practice, so that's not prescriptive enough. An act of parliament? A contract? Speaking in my capacity as humpty dumpty, I could use it to mean something that's not like Christianity, Judaism, Islam etc. It's a statement of difference but also perhaps of exclusion. I've never been a Roman Catholic but I imagine their attitude to the Virgin Mary could be a bit borderline-pagan sometimes, so I could therefore imagine a vicar advising someone that their understanding is "a bit too pagan for comfort."
  • Create New...