Jump to content
Galaemar Laerareon

Welcome Guest!

Welcome to UK Pagan; The Valley

Like most online communities we require you to register for an account before we give you access to read and post.

Only a small number of our forum areas can be read without registering for an account.

Please consider supporting us to help keep our Website and Facebook groups online. Become a Patron!

Teen Witch Article

Guest Alistair

Recommended Posts

This is something I wrote a while ago, that I'm revisiting now. It's quite out of date and the teen witch fad seems to have passed, but I thought I'd put it up here for comments or thoughts.


I'm exempting it from the Creative Commons License and retain all rights.



Where did all the Teenage Witches come from?


Alistair XXXXXXXX argues that they’re a creation of the media and marketing in the 90s, but the pagan community has a strong responsibility towards them now.



I was a Teenage Witch!


Well, sort of…


I ‘d read a fair bit and was doing my own small spells and rituals. This was a few years before the Internet made information about witchcraft and paganism easily available. The Farrars’ A Witches’ Bible seemed to be the choice for young people of my era wanting to learn about real Witchcraft. It was a wonderfully gothic looking tome which could sometimes be found sitting in bookshops drawing attention to itself, with that title promising that it was some kind of encyclopaedic doorway to forbidden magical knowledge.


Back then, serious books on magic or witchcraft were exceedingly hard to come by unless you knew exactly where to look. A Witches’ Bible seemed like a naughty artefact that the larger chain bookshops would sell more as a novelty item with an arcane curiosity value, than out of a commitment to cater for people wanting to learn about the subject.


Now, with experience, I know that it’s a fairly decent book about Wicca-flavoured witchcraft, but the magic word ‘Bible’ in the title, together with the idea that it was some kind of heretical Witches’ Bible in opposition to the regular Bible, and the white on black drawings on the front of broomsticks and ritual tools, were what made it seem so appealing back then.


I saw it on the shelves many times, but never had either enough nerve or cash to buy it, so my first book on Witchcraft actually written by a witch, was Doreen Valiente’s Witchcraft for Tomorrow, much later.


Nowadays, there’s a whole industry selling books on Witchcraft aimed at teenagers and the ‘Teen Witch’ is a demographic that the pagan community, once closed to anyone who wasn’t able to pass for grown-up, is having to deal with.


Let’s not beat about the bush here – a lot of the books and material aimed at these kids is exploitative rubbish intended to rid them of their money without actually imparting any useful information, whilst feeding the egos of the authors by setting them up as wise gurus. They’re sold to people wanting to use spells as a ready-made quick-fix solution and contain little in the way of spirituality.


There have always been the weird kids who are into the dark and spooky, and then there are those who come to paganism through environmentalism, but there’s another aspect to it now, which needs to be understood – the ways that media representations inspire people.


So – back to 'I was a Teenage Witch'.


There wasn’t actually a film called that made in the 1950s, but there might well have been. There were, however, a lot of horror films aimed at teenagers with titles like I was a Teenage Werewolf or I was a Teenage Frankenstein.


Teenagers, and all the physical changes that come with puberty were seen as scary in an America that was just starting to openly talk about such things, so they added these into the mix of cinematic monstrosities to reflect back at the audience some of the fears of society, as well as fears of the supernatural kind. These films don’t seem very scary at all now, but teenage rebellion was a very real issue in a 50s America that was struggling with its identity as a nation.


They way that these fears were safely contained was to provide wholesome equivalents. One of these first appeared in Archie comic and was the squeaky clean and friendly Sabrina the Teenage Witch. That’s where the phrase ‘Teenage Witch’ came from. We’ve still got the TV series, but it was comics that were trying to make wholesome the horror films of the 50s that first used the term.


There are two very significant British contributions to the idea and fictional evolution of the Teen Witch. Jill Murphy’s wonderful The Worst Witch was published in 1975, and for perhaps the first time showed in both prose and pictures young girls studying and practicing magic and spells, wearing pointy hats, riding broomsticks and other doing other witchy things.


There was also, in early 80s, a magazine called Misty aimed at teenage girls, which was mostly supernatural mystery stories but also featured articles about tarot cards, fortune telling, astrology, and mythology. The ‘hostess’ of this magazine was a very goddess-like ‘Lady of the Mists’ called ‘Misty’. I know for a fact that the editor of Misty was pagan, and I’m sure he didn’t have any kind of agenda to convert his readership into witches, but he was putting these kinds of things into a magazine that had a large teenage female readership and could be bought in almost any newsagent. In Misty, this editor made sure that things like witches, pagan gods and mythology were presented in a positive and fairly accurate way.


Now, we come to the time when I was reading about magic and witchcraft, and meeting other pagans for the first time - the early 90s. There’s a groundswell of interest and more books being published with ‘Wicca’ or ‘Witch’ in the title, and the Internet leading to easy communication between groups and organisations. Paganism was growing and spreading.


Now, you knew I was going to mention this sometime, so there it is - 'The Craft'.


Hollywood figures that there’s a teenage girl demographic they could aim a horror film at. There’s a vague tradition in Hollywood of hiring consultants to advise when producing films. The producers of The Craft hired a representative of a pagan organisation - The Covenant Of The Goddess - as an advisor. This advisor was put in the strange position of being both asked for contributions which would make the Witchcraft seem authentic, but also being told that it was a fantasy film which wasn’t going to take the material too seriously.


What we got was some fairly accurate Wiccan terminology with the casting of circles and calling of quarters shown and a representation of a dedication ritual with what were once supposed to be secret passwords revealed onscreen. This was in addition to the special effects-led fantasy elements such as flying. So, there were a few authentic bits, but it’s still largely a fantasy film.


However – what you do have, and this is the important bit, is a group of outsiders, gaining confidence and empowerment through practicing Witchcraft. Up until the fantasy elements kick in, this is clearly being shown. The girls in The Craft are a group of friends becoming more attractive, having better social lives, and being better able to deal with the pressures of school, through getting together to practice magic.


The Craft led to Charmed, which also borrowed terms from ‘proper’ witchcraft, and used the word ‘Wicca’ and also the ‘Rule of Three’, which is based on the Wiccan law of threefold return. We’ve also got the original Teen Witch, Sabrina on television, and although that’s further away still from the real thing, these are all young role models who call themselves Witches.


Now, I’m not saying that all the young witches that are around nowadays were inspired by these fictional creations. It’s more of a two-way thing, with the growth of paganism and the media portrayal of witches influencing each other. However, what a few writers did latch onto was the term ‘Teen Witch’.


And this is where it all goes wrong.


The various books with ‘Teen Witch’ in the title or subtitle, so far without exception (and yes, for the sake of research, I’ve read most of them) seem to be aimed at people who want to emulate the on-screen role models. The writers insert themselves into their books as fountains of knowledge and wise advice and promise that the spells that the books are padded out with can solve all of their readers’ problems.


There’s a lack of honesty about where the practices that these writers are handing down come from. They say ‘Real Witches do this…’ or ‘Real Witches never do this…’ and with almost every instance I’ve been able to think of exceptions.


There’s little context or background given, and the advice about the things that matter to teenagers, like school, relationships, sex, drugs, booze, friends, bullying, parents etc is little better than that in the problems pages of any teen magazine, and often worse - because they might convince teenagers to try magic as a substitute for practical solutions which may be more appropriate.


The writers either seem to be overbearing motherly types who feel they know what’s best, because they have teenage children of their own, or are deadly serious born-again pagans who fear a return to The Burning Times and seem to expect to be constantly persecuted for their beliefs and offer advice about that to about this, rather than about anything more useful and relevant to day to day life.


These books seem to be trying to shape their readers before they get on to other material or think too much for themselves, and don’t really seem to be an accurate representation of what does go on, on the pagan scene or what Witches really do. The only reason I can think of for this is to bolster the egos and wallets of the authors. They promise empowerment, but don’t deliver real knowledge or information about the whole realm of paganism, witchcraft or magic. The same goes for certain Witchcraft organisations that market their events at teenagers.


In many ways what they are offering is a trade off – If you do this, all your problems will be solved BUT many people will want to persecute you for solving them in this way and for using word like ‘Witch’ to describe yourself. There’s a hint of truth in this, perhaps, but it seems like alongside the spell-casting problem-solving they’re also offering a form of rebellion which is as sanitised and harmless as the music that tries to pass for punk these days, which people may find appealing because of the promise that others will find it offensive.


So, from the situation maybe ten years ago where younger people seeking information, guidance and teaching were told to come back when they were a bit older, or if they were lucky were pointed at the very, very few reputable pagan youth organisations that existed, we’ve now got a very distinct figure of the ‘Teen Witch’ in the media and society, who we can’t and definitely now shouldn’t just tell to come back when they’re older, because if we do there’s plenty of other groups who’ll view them greedily.


Today’s Teen Witches are in danger of being given very bad advice, exploited and ripped off by profit-driven organisations which are all too often unaccountable commercial businesses masquerading as spiritual movements.


This risk has always been there, but now with the whole Teen Witch concept there are far more kids that we’ve got to take some responsibility for.


Maybe as pagans, this isn’t something we wanted or asked for, but it’s something we’ve got to think about and the serious pagan organisations which actually do hold ethics above profits shouldn’t just turn the younger seekers away, but should find some way of giving them what they need, which is good advice and the way towards knowledge, instead of just selling them a pre-packaged persecution complex.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...
Please consider supporting us to help keep our Website and Facebook groups online.

Well Alistair, that was some post! :lol:


I agree that this 'Teen Witch' thing has taken off in a big way and not all for the good. T.V. programmes didn't help either. Many young brains think that all you have to do is call yourself a witch and you can cause some misfortune to someone you don't like.


We know that these films are just entertainment but young people are impresionable.


Back in the 70's, the wiccan path was also exploited by many publicity seekers claiming to be true wiccans/witches. It was a time of free love and hippies, going against the grain of structuted conformity. These people also set themselves up as priest or priestess's and lured many into their so-called rituals.


Now the internet has made it easier and the only hope is that if any of these young people decide to follow or look into this path, that they come across a proper forum like this one.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Moonsmith
      I’ve posted a link (in links) to a BBC article in today’s news just to illustrate a bit of the colourful side of Paganism.  Perhaps it will do something to balance my prosaic take on the subject. i know little of Witchcraft but I enjoyed the article and like her approach.  
    • Ellinas
      👍 It's as good a position as any and better than quite a few.  
    • Stonehugger
      Yes, it was in Nettle's "Who are your deities?" thread. I said "I seem to have become an atheist. That was never my plan, but here I am." Veggiedancer later said it better than me - "I don’t exactly believe in deities as such. I think they come from  our minds. Archetypes, ways of identify or characterising the spirit/ magic/ life or whatever it is we sense around us. Ways our minds try to explain the unexplainable to us???"
    • Moonsmith
      I’m probably second guessing Nettle wrongly but it wasn’t all that long ago that you would have read posts about alters, magic, Shamanism, spells etc. I think it was either Teatimetreat or Drachenfach that had a hex on her handbag and her car.  When the car was stolen it crashed and the thief was caught. I agree and would very much like to see more of the colourful side of Paganism back here.  Quite right Ellinas.  I do not understand how anyone can claim to be Pantheist (or even pantheist) and atheist at the same time even though the most prominent Pantheists do exactly that.  As I’ve said elsewhere: why can’t they call themselves Panists.  The prefix “pan” means everything and everywhere as in “pandemic”.  The god’s name arose from the adjective so it wouldn’t necessarily mean a devotee of Pan. pee ess - it may be worth mentioning that there are a vast number of belief groups under the umbrella word Paganism.  Druids Witches, Polytheist and Shaman are only a small part of what the greater picture of Paganism depicts. Dunno and don’t care are probably the biggest groups.
    • Ellinas
      All the above, plus the impression of a preponderance of atheism is currently, as well as historically, inaccurate.  Certainly, I am no atheist.  I believe MS rejects the term as applicable to himself.  Stonehugger, I think, recently said he had headed in that direction, but I've not seen the other resident atheists for a while. However, our ideas of deity are not the same, necessarily.
  • Create New...